Dumbest experts ever

Sport Illustrated has a poll in their most recent magazine regarding building a team. 14 experts were polled and asked who each would pick has the player he/she would want to start their team with. It is an extremely interesting question and almost impossible to get it wrong, but they did. #1 was easy, Jose Reyes, but #2 was a complete surprise, Jonathan Papelbon. I am a Sox fan, but not even the most hard core would think he is the second best player in any respect. He isn't even the player i would pick off the Sox to start a team with. I would take both Dice-K and Beckett over Paps. Paps is a closer, an until he becomes a start is not special. I love him but come on, #2.

He looked GREAT last night, though.